Teeth grinding guards: Why does mine cause pain?

Why night guards are meant to help, not hurt

We all know how night guards prevent teeth grinding damage. When fitted correctly, they act as a buffer, absorbing force and allowing your jaw muscles to relax overnight.

A proper night guard should:

Discomfort is not part of the design. Pain is the body's way of saying something is off. That “something” could be the fit, the material, your bite alignment, or even changes in your teeth since the guard was made. Understanding the cause is the first step toward real relief.

Find a night guard that actually works with your bite

Custom-made options are designed to protect, not strain, your teeth and jaw.

Buy a custom night guard

Common reasons your grinding guard causes pain

Poor fit and bite alignment issues

One of the most common reasons night guards for teeth grinding cause pain is a poor fit. Generic mouth guards for grinding teeth often don't match your bite, which can create uneven pressure on certain teeth. Over time, this can lead to morning soreness, bite discomfort, or new sensitivity, especially for people who clench heavily. Pain that appears weeks after starting a guard is often a sign that fit, not usage, is the problem.

Hard or rigid materials that don't absorb force well

Not all night guards absorb pressure the same way. Hard guards can be durable, but without precise customization, they may concentrate force instead of dispersing it evenly. For heavy grinders, this can feel like constant pressure on specific teeth rather than relief. Softer or hybrid materials are often more forgiving when clenching is a major factor.

Jaw misalignment and TMJ strain

A poorly designed night guard can alter how your jaw closes during sleep. When this happens, jaw muscles may stay tense overnight instead of relaxing, leading to morning tightness, headaches, or joint discomfort. People with TMJ sensitivity are especially affected. A night guard should support natural jaw positioning, not force a new one.

The normal adjustment period (and when it's over)

Some mild discomfort during the first few days of wearing a new night guard is normal. Most adjustment periods last between three days and two weeks. What matters is improvement. If discomfort worsens or lasts beyond two weeks, it's no longer an adjustment issue but a sign of poor fit.

Recent dental work or natural tooth shifting

Teeth naturally shift over time, and dental work such as fillings or orthodontic treatment can subtly change your bite. A night guard that once fit comfortably may no longer align properly, leading to pressure or pain. This is why night guards should be reassessed after dental changes, even if they previously worked well.

When pain is not normal: Red flags to watch for

Some symptoms should never be ignored. If your night guard is causing any of the following, it's time to stop wearing it and seek a solution:

What to do if your night guard hurts

Start with gradual wear

If the guard is new, try easing into it. Wearing it for short periods during the day can help your jaw muscles adapt without the prolonged pressure of overnight use.

Five to ten minutes at a time is enough to gauge whether discomfort decreases or intensifies. If pain appears immediately, the issue is likely structural rather than adjustment-related.

Soothe irritation before bed

Warm saltwater rinses can help calm irritated gums and reduce inflammation, especially if the edges are rubbing or pressing against soft tissue. While this won't fix a poorly fitting guard, it can make short-term discomfort more manageable while you plan next steps.

Get a professional assessment

A dentist can quickly identify pressure points, bite imbalance, or material issues. In some cases, minor adjustments can resolve the problem.

However, if the guard itself is fundamentally mismatched to your bite, adjustment may only be a temporary fix.

Upgrade to a custom-fit night guard

This is where most long-term relief comes from.

Custom-made night guards are the best night guards for teeth grinding. They are designed from impressions of your teeth, not an average mold. They align with your bite, distribute pressure evenly, and reduce the risk of tooth shifting or jaw strain.

For people dealing with persistent discomfort, custom-fit guards are often the turning point between nightly pain and actual protection.

Caspersmile's custom night guards are designed to fit your exact bite, helping prevent pressure points, gum irritation, and jaw discomfort while still protecting against grinding damage. If your guard hurts, it's not doing its job. Comfort and protection should go hand in hand.

Find a night guard that actually works

If your current guard causes pain, pressure, or sensitivity, it's not designed for your bite. A custom-fit night guard protects your teeth and jaw without discomfort.

Upgrade to a custom night guard

Types of night guards and their comfort levels

Soft night guards

Soft guards are typically recommended for mild grinders. They feel cushioned and comfortable, but may wear down faster for people who clench aggressively.

They're often a good starting point, but not always a long-term solution.

Hard night guards

Hard guards are extremely durable and ideal for severe grinding. However, without precise customization, they can feel rigid and unforgiving, especially for sensitive teeth or TMJ-prone jaws.

Fit matters more than firmness.

Hybrid night guards

Hybrid guards combine a soft inner layer with a hard outer shell. This design balances comfort and durability, making it a popular option for moderate to heavy grinders who need protection without excessive rigidity.

Many people find hybrids easier to tolerate long-term.

How to prevent night guard pain in the future

Comfort doesn't end once you find the right guard. Ongoing care matters.

Replacing your guard every one to three years helps maintain proper fit and hygiene. Storing it away from heat prevents warping. Cleaning it regularly reduces gum irritation and bacterial buildup.

Most importantly, reassess your guard after any dental work or bite changes. What fit once may not fit forever.

When it's time to replace your night guard entirely

There are moments when adjustment is no longer enough.

If your guard cracks, warps, feels unstable, or continues to cause pain despite professional tweaks, replacing it is the safer option. Persistent pressure, shifting teeth, or jaw discomfort are signs the guard is working against you.

A new, custom-fit guard can restore comfort and protect your teeth before damage sets in.

What should you do if your night guard hurts

A night guard is supposed to make mornings easier, not introduce new aches, pressure, or sensitivity. If wearing one leaves your teeth sore or your jaw tight, that discomfort isn't something to push through. It's useful information. Pain usually means the guard doesn't match your bite, your grinding pattern, or your current dental anatomy anymore.

The takeaway is simple: relief comes from the right guard, not just any guard. Understanding why your current one hurts, whether it's fit, material, jaw alignment, or natural tooth changes, is the first step toward fixing the problem instead of tolerating it. With a properly designed, custom-fit night guard, comfort and protection can finally exist together, the way they're meant to.

Frequently asked questions

Why do my teeth hurt after wearing a mouth guard? +

Tooth pain usually comes from uneven pressure, a poor fit, or material that doesn’t absorb grinding force properly. Pain is not a normal long-term effect.

Do night guards ever make grinding pain worse? +

Yes, especially if they alter bite alignment or concentrate pressure on certain teeth. A poorly fitted guard can worsen jaw tension and tooth sensitivity.

How can I make my mouth guard more comfortable? +

Ensuring proper fit, choosing the right material, and switching to a custom-made guard are the most effective ways to improve comfort.

Why do dentists recommend night guards so often? +

Because grinding causes irreversible damage. Night guards are a preventive tool that protects enamel, reduces jaw strain, and helps avoid costly dental repairs.

Are there negative effects of wearing a night guard? +

Only when the guard is poorly fitted, worn too long without replacement, or mismatched to your bite. A well-designed, custom-fit guard should not cause harm.