November 25, 2025
Key takeaways
The failure rate for bonded retainers is relatively high, with studies reporting an overall failure rate of approximately 30% to 40%. The risk of failure increases over time, with nearly 25% of failures occurring in the first year and the risk growing to nearly 50% by the 6-year mark. Failure is more common in the upper jaw and with longer retainer spans.
Factors influencing failure rate
Time: The risk of failure increases significantly with the duration of follow-up.
Arch: The maxillary (upper) arch has a higher failure rate than the mandibular (lower) arch.
Length of retainer: Longer retainers that span more teeth have a higher risk of breakage.
Previous issues: Retainer failures are more likely to occur if there were previous defects in the area.
Type of retainer: While some studies show a higher failure rate for certain types of retainers (like ribbon retainers), the differences are often not statistically significant.
Common types of failure
Detachment: The retainer wire detaches from the tooth surface.
Composite damage: The composite material holding the retainer fails.
Breakage: The wire itself breaks, which can be more common with longer spans or certain materials.
Survival and maintenance
While failure is common, a well-bonded retainer can last for many years without needing replacement.
Some studies show high survival rates over longer periods, with 98.9% of mandibular and 97.6% of maxillary retainers still in place after 10-15 years.
The frequency of maintenance is influenced by the factors above. Patients with a greater risk of failure may need to see an orthodontist more frequently for maintenance.
Table of Content
How bonded retainers work
A bonded retainer is a thin wire glued to the back of your front teeth — usually the lower ones — to keep them in place after braces or aligners. Whether the bonded retainers are for upper teeth or lower, their main job is simple: to stop your teeth from moving back to where they were and to help you hold on to that straight smile. The wire is attached with a strong dental adhesive, so it stays put without you having to think about it. It's like a little safety net, keeping your teeth stable while your gums and bone adjust after treatment.
Of course, no solution is perfect. Bonded retainers have their benefits, but there are also a few downsides to consider. Let's take a closer look at the pros and cons so you know what to expect.
Pros and cons of bonded retainers
Bonded permanent retainers are a favorite for many because they're simple, effective, and low-maintenance.
Pros of bonded retainers
Here's why people love them:
-
Discreet and invisible: The wire sits quietly behind your teeth, so no one can see it — not even when you smile or talk. It just does its thing in the background, keeping everything in place without drawing any attention.
-
Hassle-free convenience: There's nothing to put in, take out, or remember. Your bonded retainer stays right where it is and works around the clock. If you're busy or just don't want the extra responsibility of a removable retainer, this part is a huge plus.
-
Keeps teeth in place: After braces, it's normal to worry about your teeth shifting back. A bonded retainer takes that stress off your shoulders. It holds your teeth steady so all the time and money you invested in straightening them doesn't go to waste.
-
Long-lasting results: With a bit of care, these retainers can stay in great shape for years. They're a solid way to protect your smile long-term and keep your results looking just the way you want.
Cons of bonded retainers
They're helpful, but they're not perfect. Here's what's good to keep in mind:
-
Harder to clean around: Because the wire sits behind your teeth, brushing and flossing can take a little extra effort. Food and plaque can get stuck around it if you're not paying attention, which might irritate your gums. A floss threader or water flosser makes the whole thing way easier.
-
Adjustment period: When you first get it, your tongue might keep bumping into the wire, and things may feel a little weird. Some people notice mild soreness too. It's normal, and most of the time you'll forget it's even there after a few days or weeks.
-
Risk of breakage: Hard or sticky foods can easily mess with the wire. If it bends or comes loose, your teeth can start shifting again. If something feels off, just get it checked. It's usually a small fix if you catch it early.
-
Cost considerations: Bonded retainers can cost a bit more than removable ones, both when you get them and if they ever need repairs. But many people don't mind the extra cost because it saves them the hassle of remembering to wear a retainer every day.
-
Limited coverage: These retainers mostly hold the front teeth in place. They don't do much for the back teeth, so those can still move a bit over time. It's not a huge issue for most people, but it's something to know.
-
Extra attention for oral hygiene: Because of the wire, food and bacteria can settle in spots that are harder to reach. Staying consistent with brushing, flossing, and your regular dental checkups keeps everything healthy and clean.
As you can see, bonded retainers do come with a few small drawbacks. They do interrupt cleaning, eating, and other aspects of daily life. That's why we're seeing a rising attraction toward clear removable retainers. They aren't too visible. Plus, you can remove them whenever you like, without disrupting your day.
Think removable retainers are the solution for you?
Caspersmile Removable Retainers can maintain your smile without the hassle of bonded ones.
Maintaining oral hygiene with a bonded retainer
Taking care of your bonded retainer isn't hard, but you do have to pay a little attention. Food can get stuck around the wire, and if you don't clean it, your gums or teeth could get unhappy. Here's what I'd do:
-
Brush gently a couple of times a day: Use a soft toothbrush and some fluoride toothpaste. Don't scrub too hard around the wire — just make sure you're getting the plaque off.
-
Floss, even if it's a pain: The wire makes it tricky, but a floss threader or a water flosser can help. It's worth it to get the bits out from between your teeth.
-
Be careful with sticky or hard stuff: Caramel, gum, hard candy — those can bend or break the wire. If that happens, your teeth could start moving again, and nobody wants that.
-
Go to your checkups: Your dentist or orthodontist can make sure everything's still in place and that your teeth haven't shifted. Catching small problems early saves a lot of hassle later.
While bonded retainers don't challenge your discipline, they certainly are a hassle to deal with. There are food restrictions, a lisp initially, and issues with maintaining oral health care. So, before you decide, do have a look at the removable retainer option. It might make holding on to that smile much easier.
When to repair or replace your bonded retainer
Even though your retainer is called permanent, it still needs attention now and then. You'll want to give your orthodontist a call if you notice any of these things:
-
The wire feels loose or is coming off: If it's wiggly or not sitting right, your teeth could start moving. Getting it fixed quickly keeps everything in place.
-
Your teeth feel like they're shifting: Even a tiny change in alignment can mean the retainer isn't doing its job. Don't wait — a quick check can prevent bigger problems.
-
The area around the retainer is sore or irritated: Some irritation is normal at first, but if it pops up later or sticks around, it could mean the wire is rubbing the wrong way. A simple visit can make it comfortable again.
Fixing small problems early is always easier than dealing with bigger ones later, and it keeps your smile exactly where it should be.
Bonded vs removable retainers: What's better for you?
Choosing the best retainer between bonded and removable can feel a little confusing at first, but it doesn't have to be. Here's a simple comparison to help you see the pros and quirks of each one.
|
Feature |
Bonded (Permanent) retainer |
Removable retainer |
|
Visibility |
Hidden behind teeth |
Visible when worn |
|
Maintenance |
Always in place |
Must be removed and cleaned |
|
Hygiene |
Harder to clean |
Easier to brush and floss |
|
Risk of Breakage |
Possible with hard foods |
Can be lost or damaged |
|
Longevity |
Long-lasting with care |
May need replacement over time |
Now that you've seen the ups and downs of permanent bonded retainers, it's easier to see what might work best for your smile. Everyone's teeth and lifestyle are different, so thinking about your habits, comfort, and how much maintenance you're willing to do can help you decide whether a bonded retainer or maybe a removable one is the right fit for you.
Ready to figure out the best option for your smile?
Get personalized guidance from a dental professional without leaving home.
Finding the right balance
Fixed bonded retainers are a great way to keep your teeth in place after braces or aligners. They're reliable and completely hidden from view. But they require a little attention when it comes to brushing and flossing. Plus, there might be a few food restrictions, at least initially. And if that's a problem for you, consider removable retainers. They might be a better fit.
Still, consult your dentist before making the final decision. And, no matter what type you choose, don't neglect using a retainer. That new smile is worth protecting.
Frequently asked questions
References
The Healthline Editorial Team. (2018b, May 29). What to know before you get a retainer. Healthline.
https://www.healthline.com/health/retainer-types
Higuera, V. (2019d, December 20). Pros and cons of permanent retainers. Healthline.
https://www.healthline.com/health/permanent-retainer
Share This Article
Subscribe our newsletter
By clicking subscribe, you agree to our Privacy Policy and opt in to receive communications from Caspersmile. You can unsubscribe at any time.
